When a billion-dollar AI company nearly imploded in a single week, the headlines focused on drama—but the real story was a governance failure every in-house lawyer should study. The OpenAI governance lessons for in-house lawyers reveal how quickly structural flaws can destabilize even the most innovative companies, especially when governance doesn’t keep pace with a rapidly evolving business model.
Duane Valz, an experienced startup executive and former general counsel, unpacks what happened, why it matters, and the lessons every corporate counsel can take away.
Watch the full conversation with Duane Valz here:
OpenAI began with a nonprofit structure dedicated to artificial general intelligence research. But when its technology leapt from R&D experiments to a billion-dollar commercial product almost overnight, its governance framework didn’t evolve alongside it. Duane explains that this mismatch—between a mission built for long-term public benefit and the reality of running a high-growth commercial enterprise—created a structural strain. Tax rules, board composition, and fiduciary duties in a nonprofit model can conflict with investor expectations and market pressures, leaving the company vulnerable to internal rifts.
Why Changing Structures Gets Harder With Success
The OpenAI episode also highlights how difficult it is to make structural changes after success arrives. When valuations soar and public visibility explodes, even obvious fixes become politically complicated. Duane notes that while the board could have restructured to better reflect its commercial reality, the opportunity for a smooth transition had largely passed once the company became a global name.
CEO Incentives and Board Alignment
Another unusual wrinkle was CEO Sam Altman’s lack of significant equity. While his reputation, influence, and strategic opportunities provided strong incentives to lead effectively, Olga points out that traditional equity or vesting schedules often serve as an additional alignment tool between a CEO and their board. Without them, the balance of power and accountability can shift in unpredictable ways.
Lessons for In-House Lawyers
For in-house lawyers, the OpenAI case is more than Silicon Valley gossip—it’s a reminder that governance must evolve with your business. Whether you’re guiding a startup through rapid growth or steering a mature company into new markets, governance structures should be designed to handle both day-to-day operations and moments of crisis. In AI, regulatory and public scrutiny can arrive much earlier than expected, amplifying the need for resilient and adaptable governance.
The Big Takeaway
Duane’s closing reflection is that governance isn’t just about stability—it’s about readiness. Companies must be able to navigate both the opportunities and the breakdowns that success brings. Olga emphasizes that good governance protects not only shareholder value but also the integrity of the mission. The OpenAI governance lessons make one thing clear: without the right structures, even the most visionary companies can face avoidable crises.
Watch the full conversation here: Notes to My (Legal) Self: Season 6, Episode 16 (ft.Duane Valz)
Join the Conversation
At Notes to My (Legal) Self®, we help in-house legal professionals sharpen their skills, expand their leadership toolkit, and stay ahead of industry shifts. From governance strategy to legal operations and emerging tech, we’re here to help you navigate complex challenges with clarity.
What’s your biggest governance “aha” moment? Share your story with us.
