When AI fails, we blame the code. But the real risk? Legal exclusion in AI governance. Too often, engineers build in isolation—without lawyers, ethicists, or compliance teams at the table. The result? Technically sound tools that crumble under legal scrutiny or public backlash. Recognizing Legal’s Role in AI Governance is crucial to avoid these pitfalls.
Here’s why legal leadership in AI development isn’t optional—it’s the foundation of responsible innovation.
The Cost of Ignoring Legal in AI Governance
I once worked with a team that developed an AI risk assessment tool. On paper, it was everything you’d want: fast, clean, efficient, technically robust. But when it was tested in real-world scenarios, things went sideways. The tool disproportionately flagged certain demographics, skewing outcomes in a way that was hard to defend and even harder to explain.
The intent wasn’t malicious. The team had simply worked in isolation. There were no legal voices in the room. No one from ethics. No feedback from the people the tool would ultimately impact. It was a technically impressive system built without context, and that context turned out to be everything.
How Legal Teams Transform AI Development
What solved the problem wasn’t a new algorithm—it was a shift in how the team worked. We brought in legal. We brought in compliance, ethics, and policy. And most importantly, we engaged people who understood how the tool would land in the real world. The result wasn’t just a less biased product—it was a better one.
It worked more fairly. It was easier to explain. And it earned trust that we hadn’t even realized we were at risk of losing.
Legal Isn’t a Hurdle—It’s a Design Partner
This experience revealed legal’s role in AI governance isn’t about obstruction—it’s about acceleration. When engaged early, legal teams don’t just mitigate risk; they illuminate blind spots in fairness and compliance that others miss. Their unique perspective transforms what we build and how we build it.
Legal professionals exercising their role in AI governance ask the tough questions about accountability that engineers might overlook. They identify regulatory pitfalls before they become crises. Beyond protection, they actively shape technology to be both innovative and responsible—proving legal’s role in AI governance is about building better systems, not just safer ones.
The lesson is clear: When we embrace legal’s role in AI governance from the start, we don’t limit innovation—we future-proof it. Their partnership doesn’t create roadblocks; it builds guardrails for sustainable progress.
It’s Time to Move Legal Upstream
Forward-thinking organizations are charting a different course. They’re embedding legal counsel in AI projects from day one, creating a continuous feedback loop between innovation and governance. In these environments, legal doesn’t just mitigate risk – it becomes a strategic advantage.
These teams don’t waste time retrofitting compliance onto finished products. Instead, they bake ethical considerations and regulatory requirements into the design itself. The result? AI systems that move faster in the long run because they’re built on legally sound foundations from the start.
This Is Legal’s Leadership Moment
As AI becomes increasingly embedded in business operations, legal’s role is evolving from interpreter to innovator. The most effective legal teams aren’t just reading regulations – they’re helping define how values translate into code. They’re moving beyond compliance checklists to architect systems that are explainable, equitable, and engineered for trust.
Build Trust Before You Need It
That risk assessment tool taught me an enduring lesson: AI’s most dangerous flaws aren’t in the code – they’re in the conversations we don’t have. The stakeholders we fail to consult. The legal perspectives we exclude until it’s too late.
If your organization is building AI – and most are – consider this: Are you having those critical conversations now, while they can shape your technology? Or will you wait until a crisis forces them upon you? The answer may determine whether your AI initiatives become assets or liabilities.
Join the Conversation
At Notes to My (Legal) Self®, we’re dedicated to helping in-house legal professionals develop the skills, insights, and strategies needed to thrive in today’s evolving legal landscape. From leadership development to legal operations optimization and emerging technology, we provide the tools to help you stay ahead.
What’s been your biggest breakthrough moment in your legal career? Let’s talk about it—share your story.
