A chief legal officer once told me that the hardest part of leading in the AI era isn’t spotting risk. It’s what happens next. She recalled a Friday afternoon when her team discovered that a vendor’s GenAI tool had been trained on internal product documents containing confidential information. The problem wasn’t the breach itself; it was what came after. Her inbox filled with messages that started with words like urgent, catastrophic, and potential exposure.
By the time she walked into the CEO’s office, she had rewritten her talking points three times. She wanted to be transparent without inciting panic, decisive without dramatizing. What she said changed the tone of the entire response. “We’ve identified a data governance gap,” she began. “We have isolated the system, contained the risk, and are taking two specific steps to prevent recurrence. Here’s what I need from you.”
The message was calm, factual, and forward-looking. The CEO listened, nodded, and said one word: “Good.” That is what effective escalation looks like in the AI era.
Redefine Escalation: AI Risk Escalation for GCs as a Leadership Act
Escalation is not about sounding alarms. It is about converting uncertainty into direction. Too many legal teams treat escalation as a reaction, something done because a rule requires it. In reality, it is a leadership behavior that determines whether a company overreacts, underreacts, or responds with confidence.
Start by defining escalation clearly within your organization. Document what qualifies as an AI misuse event. Examples include using training data without proper licensing, deploying an untested AI tool that processes sensitive data, or generating content that violates privacy, bias, or IP standards. For each category, outline what level of management should be notified and what immediate containment steps should occur.
The goal is to make escalation a predictable process rather than an emotional one. Everyone in the company should know what happens next when AI crosses a boundary.
Create Triggers That Move, Not Paralyze, the Organization
Most escalation failures happen because teams freeze between recognition and communication. They hesitate, fearing overreaction or blame. Clear triggers eliminate that hesitation. Define three levels of escalation based on impact and exposure.
Low-level triggers involve internal review, documentation, and remediation. Medium-level triggers require notification to Legal and the business sponsor with a short written summary of facts, potential risk, and next steps. High-level triggers activate executive or board notice within 24 hours.
The difference between overreaction and effective leadership is timing. Escalate early enough to inform decisions but not so early that you create unnecessary noise. Establish a threshold rule: escalate when the issue could reasonably affect customers, regulators, investors, or employees. When in doubt, escalate with clarity, not panic.
Write the Playbook Before You Need It
The time to write your escalation memo is not after the crisis. Build templates now. Create a one-page form that captures key facts: what happened, how it was discovered, what systems are affected, who is informed, and what immediate mitigation has begun. This simple document is your protection against confusion later. It ensures that every escalation looks professional, not improvised.
Assign owners for communication at each level, one voice for internal business updates, one for the board, and one for external statements if necessary. Rehearse the workflow annually as part of your risk drills. Treat it as part of your governance system, not a compliance formality.
Lead the Room When You Deliver the Message
When it is time to escalate, tone is everything. Facts matter, but delivery defines impact. Walk into the meeting prepared to do three things: establish credibility, project control, and direct attention toward solutions.
Start with what you know, not what you fear. Explain how the risk was detected and what steps are already underway. Avoid abstract language. Instead of saying “there might be exposure,” say “the model accessed data from one internal repository; we’ve isolated it and are auditing access logs.” End every escalation conversation with two proposed paths forward, one immediate and one strategic.
Escalation done well earns credibility. It shows that Legal is both the conscience and the command center of the organization.
Build the Emotional Discipline to Stay Centered
AI incidents often unfold fast and publicly. Your composure will determine how others behave. A calm GC creates alignment. An anxious GC creates noise. Before every escalation conversation, take a moment to separate what is urgent from what is dramatic. Urgency demands action; drama distracts from it.
When your team reports a potential misuse, ask three questions before responding: what is the real harm, what has already been contained, and what decision needs to be made now. This helps you frame the issue in executive language rather than emotional terms.
Train your team in this discipline too. Run tabletop exercises where lawyers practice explaining AI errors in 90 seconds, emphasizing facts, fixes, and next steps. Repetition builds confidence, and confidence builds trust.
Institutionalize Calm
The final step is to make composure part of culture. Include AI escalation in your governance framework and assign an executive sponsor responsible for post-incident reviews. After every event, debrief what went right, what lagged, and how to improve communication speed and tone. Celebrate quick, factual reporting. Reward the people who raised risks early and clearly.
When escalation is treated as a normal, professional process, it stops feeling like failure. It becomes a mark of maturity.
The Leadership Standard
AI is moving too fast for perfection to be your goal. Your role as GC is not to prevent every mistake but to make sure mistakes do not metastasize. Escalation is your pressure valve. It releases tension before it explodes.
The GCs who excel in this era are not those who shout warnings the loudest but those who can speak clearly while others are losing perspective. They design systems that surface truth quickly, communicate without fear, and act with conviction.
When AI misuse happens, and it will, remember this rule of modern leadership: the calmest person in the room sets the temperature for everyone else.
Ultimately, AI Risk Escalation for GCs is a leadership discipline: structure, calm, and speed matter more than perfect foresight.
Join the Conversation
At Notes to My (Legal) Self®, we’re dedicated to helping in-house legal professionals develop the skills, insights, and strategies needed to thrive in today’s evolving legal landscape. From leadership development to legal operations optimization and emerging technology, we provide the tools to help you stay ahead.
What’s been your biggest breakthrough moment in your legal career? Let’s talk about it—share your story.
